Nashville’s three most useful comparisons are Atlanta, Austin (technically South-Central, but close enough to draw comparisons constantly), and Charlotte. Each comparison illuminates something specific about what Nashville is and isn’t.
Nashville vs. Atlanta
Atlanta is larger, 6 million metro versus Nashville’s 2.15 million, and operates at a different scale in almost every category. Atlanta has the busiest airport in the world (Hartsfield-Jackson). Nashville has a good regional airport. Atlanta has Midtown, Buckhead, and a skyline that continues to densify. Nashville’s skyline is growing but doesn’t approach Atlanta’s concentration.
Atlanta is also culturally different in ways that matter. Atlanta has been a Black cultural capital of the American South since Reconstruction, home to HBCUs (Spelman, Morehouse, Clark Atlanta), civil rights history (Martin Luther King Jr. was born and buried there), and one of the most significant Black middle-class communities in the United States. Nashville has Fisk University and significant civil rights history of its own (the Nashville sit-ins were strategically important), but Atlanta’s scale and cultural weight in this regard is incomparable.
Where Nashville competes: healthcare industry concentration, music industry depth, cost of living (Nashville is cheaper than comparable Atlanta neighborhoods), and commute times (Nashville averages 25 minutes versus Atlanta’s 35 minutes). Nashville’s unemployment rate consistently runs below Atlanta’s. Atlanta has more traffic problems and a more challenging public transit situation despite having MARTA.
Nashville vs. Austin
The Nashville-Austin comparison is the one music city people make most often, and it has genuine merit. Both cities have live music as a central identity. Both have boomed over the past 15 years. Both have attracted tech companies fleeing California.
The differences: Austin’s tech sector is larger and more deeply embedded (Dell, IBM, Apple’s massive campus expansion, UT Austin’s engineering pipeline). Nashville’s healthcare sector has no Austin equivalent. Austin is notably hotter and drier. Nashville is greener.
Austin famously claims the title “Live Music Capital of the World” and has more live music venues per capita than Nashville. Nashville has more recording industry infrastructure, publishing deals, session musicians, and labels. Austin has more genres; Nashville has more industry. The Oracle relocation from Austin to Nashville in 2024 (Oracle left Austin after only four years) was a symbolic data point in the cities’ ongoing competition.
Cost of living: Nashville is modestly cheaper than Austin overall, particularly in housing, though the gap is narrowing.
Nashville vs. Charlotte
Charlotte and Nashville are the most direct comparison, similar-sized metros that grew rapidly over the same period and compete for the same corporate relocations and incoming residents.
Charlotte is a financial center (Bank of America and Truist Financial are headquartered there) with stronger banking and finance employment than Nashville. Nashville has no comparable financial sector concentration but leads in healthcare and entertainment.
Charlotte has better public transit: a functioning light rail system with 43 stations, versus Nashville’s bus-only WeGo network. This is a meaningful quality-of-life difference for people who don’t want to own a car.
Nashville has stronger cultural tourism, more distinct neighborhood identity, and the music industry infrastructure that Charlotte simply doesn’t have. Charlotte has a reputation for being a somewhat generic business city; Nashville has a personality.
The Bottom Line
Nashville is smaller than Atlanta, more culturally specific than Charlotte, and less tech-dominant than Austin. It punches above its weight in music industry concentration, healthcare industry significance, and tourism appeal. The honest comparison is that Nashville is one of three or four Southern cities (alongside Atlanta, Austin/Houston, and Charlotte) competing for the next tier of national city status, and it’s doing so with a more distinct identity than most of its competitors.
Sources
- U.S. Census Bureau, metropolitan area population estimates, 2024
- Nashville Area Chamber of Commerce, Regional Economic Report 2024
- Resonance/Ipsos, World’s Best Cities Report 2024
- Bureau of Labor Statistics, local area unemployment statistics, 2024
- Charlotte Area Transit System (CATS), ridership data
- Oracle Corporation, Nashville headquarters relocation announcement, 2024